Conversion · 8 min read
Why is my website not converting?
If you're getting traffic but not signups, the problem is almost never "more traffic". It's one of these nine silent killers — and each one has a fix you can ship today.
First, rule out the obvious
Before you blame the copy, confirm the basics: tracking actually fires, the signup button actually works on mobile, and the traffic you're getting is from your target audience (not a Reddit spike or bot traffic). Once those are clear, the real culprits are below.
1. Your hero doesn't say what you do
Symptom: A stranger lands on your homepage and can't tell within 5 seconds what you sell, who it's for, or why they should care. Clever taglines ("Reimagine your workflow.") feel premium but kill conversion.
Fix: Rewrite your H1 as: "[Outcome] for [Audience]". Example: "60-second conversion audits for SaaS founders." Boring beats clever every time on a homepage.
2. Too many primary CTAs
Symptom: Your hero has "Start free trial", "Book a demo", "Watch video" and "See pricing" all styled as buttons. Every extra button cuts the click-through rate on the one that actually matters.
Fix: Pick ONE primary action. Demote the rest to text links. If you genuinely need a secondary CTA, style it as a ghost button so the visual hierarchy is unmistakable.
3. Zero social proof above the fold
Symptom: No customer logos, no testimonials, no usage numbers, no ratings. Visitors don't know if you have 3 users or 30,000.
Fix: Add a logo strip, a star rating with review count, or a one-line quote with a real name and photo within the first viewport. Even "Trusted by 1,200+ founders" beats nothing.
4. Mobile is an afterthought
Symptom: On a 375px viewport, your CTA is below the fold, tap targets are tiny, text is 14px, and the hero image pushes everything down. Mobile traffic now outweighs desktop on most B2C sites.
Fix: Open your site on your own phone right now. If you have to pinch-zoom or scroll to find the button, that's the bug. Stack the hero, increase tap targets to 44px, set body to 16px.
5. Slow first paint
Symptom: Largest Contentful Paint over 2.5s. Every second of delay drops mobile conversion by ~7%.
Fix: Compress and resize your hero image, preload it, add explicit width/height, defer non-critical scripts, and remove any "just in case" font weights.
6. Friction at the moment of conversion
Symptom: Your signup form asks for 6 fields, requires a credit card before showing value, or hides pricing behind a sales call.
Fix: Cut every form field that doesn't gate the next step. Move the credit card to AFTER the user has seen value. Publish a starting price, even if it's "from $X/mo".
7. Feature-led copy instead of outcome-led copy
Symptom: Your H2s say "AI-powered analysis", "Real-time dashboards", "Enterprise-grade security". They describe what the product is, not what it does for the buyer.
Fix: Rewrite each H2 as a concrete outcome with a number when possible. "Cut audit time from 4 hours to 4 minutes." "Catch the 3 fixes that recover ~15% of dropped signups."
8. No trust signals near the CTA
Symptom: Your signup button sits in a vacuum — no guarantee, no "no credit card required", no security badge, no testimonial nearby.
Fix: Add one micro-trust signal immediately under the button: "No credit card. Cancel anytime." or "Trusted by 1,200+ teams." Friction at the moment of conversion costs more than anywhere else.
9. You've never actually watched a real visitor use it
Symptom: You've optimized based on assumptions. You've never watched a session recording or run a 5-second test.
Fix: Install a free session-replay tool. Watch 10 real sessions end-to-end. You will find at least one obvious bug or confusing element you would never have spotted from the inside.
Want all 9 checked on your site automatically?
BurnRate runs every one of these checks plus 30 more and returns a prioritized list of fixes in about 60 seconds. Free, no signup.
Audit my site free →